Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY - single-family homes for sale

6 of 6 results displayed

$1,895,000Active
4 beds 3 baths2,296 sq. ft.
73 N Midway Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 929830Listed by: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
$5,875,000Pending
2 beds 2 baths1,504 sq. ft.
21 Thompson Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 906564Listed by: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
$1,195,000Pending
3 beds 2 baths1,340 sq. ft.
10 Strawberry Lane, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 901821Listed by: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
$4,445,000Active
6 beds 8 baths5,622 sq. ft.
100 S Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 864101Listed by: DOUGLAS ELLIMAN REAL ESTATE
$2,999,000Active
3 beds 2 baths1,373 sq. ft.
13 Tarkettle Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 922865Listed by: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY
$9,955,000Active
9 beds 6 baths3,944 sq. ft.
15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS# 842673Listed by: DANIEL GALE SOTHEBYS INTL RLTY

Local realty services provided by:Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Choice Realty

Popular neighborhoods near Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY

Zip codes near Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY

Counties near Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY

Company

About Press releases Franchise BHGRE global The BHGRE Life Blog

Buy and sell

BHGRE Distinctive Collection Buy a home Sell a home All homes for sale All real estate agents All real estate offices

Resources

Find an agent Join BHGRE Offices

Terms of use Accessibility statement DMCA notice Fraud alert Privacy notice Fair housing Do not sell or share my personal information Submit agent or broker complaint

Protect your home and budget from life's surprises with an Assurant Home Warranty, backed by a partner that supports you through every step of homeownership. Explore Plans.

© 2026 Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate LLC. An Anywhere Real Estate company. All rights reserved. Better Homes and Gardens® Real Estate is a registered trademark owned by Meredith Operations Corporation, licensed to Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate LLC and used with permission. Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate LLC fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate.

Each office is independently owned and operated.

Any services or products provided by third parties are not provided by, affiliated with or related to Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate LLC, or its affiliated companies.